By: Rick O’Donnell
Looking at the worst season of the Mike McDaniel era, the Miami Dolphins can point fingers all they want. Whether they point them at the GM, Chris Grier, or HC Mike McDaniel, or QB Tua Tagovailoa, each person would share their own part of the blame for the failure of the 2025 Miami Dolphins season. Combine all those guys, and you still won’t have enough to equal the blame that falls on owner Stephen Ross.
There’s a sense of misery surrounding the Miami Dolphins that peaked this season but looks as if it started in the middle of the season last year. The Dolphins aren’t having fun anymore. As a matter of fact, the energy that was on the field the season the ‘Fins were on HBO’s Hard Knocks versus the energy the following season is night and day. The only question is, how long has this been coming, and how much blame can truly fall on Stephen Ross?
There are (small) corners of social media calling for Ross to sell the team since he won’t fire McDaniel or Grier (yet). At 85 years old, starting over with a new regime that would more than likely take three years for a full turnaround, it’s understandable why he is hesitant. However, the problem isn’t just the coach and players; it’s the organization.
Miami has hired the up-and-coming football minds. They’ve hired skilled offensive coordinators as well as defensive coordinators at the helm. Ross has hired player-friendly coaches as well as the no-nonsense “old school” minds. Nothing seems to be working.
So what’s broken about the Miami Dolphins?
Look at the press conferences you see after games this year, something seems off. Not just because the team is losing, either. Does anyone else get the sense that when they interview players, or coaches, or the GM, there’s a whole vibe of “I don’t know, I just work here”? It’s almost as if they have no say over what happens to the team. Then dig a little deeper.
The rebuild within the Miami Dolphins started with Mike McDaniel. Chris Grier had stockpiled picks, had the cap space, and was given a clean slate to build the team. Miami was in position for their turn around. They could draft and develop players while building depth on their roster. Then they started winning, and all of a sudden they were trading for big-name players and throwing money around as if they had it to burn. The Dolphins went from having 12-13 picks in the first few seasons to 6-7 the past two. There’s also limited cap space for them to take on players to fix holes.
But go back a bit further.
Just before the McDaniel hire, Ross was looking to bring in Tom Brady, which led to a tampering case and penalty from the league. Ross would also go on to heavily court Sean Payton to be his HC and eventually get rejected. It’s quite clear that the Dolphins’ owner wanted to make as many moves as he could to make his team relevant in pursuit of a Super Bowl, which, to an extent, is not a bad thing.
However, it’s the sum of the whole that we have to question. Was Stephen Ross too involved with the decisions of the Miami Dolphins? Was he the one facilitating the pursuit of Brady/Payton? Could the reason the Dolphins went out and traded for a Bradley Chubb or Tyreek Hill have been pressure from ownership? Is the reason Miami is throwing out big contracts instead of stockpiling picks to fill out their roster coming from the top?
Maybe Stephen Ross is right. Despite the frustration on social media, the problem isn’t really Mike McDaniel. He’s been dealing the hand he’s been dealt. Chris Grier hasn’t filled out the roster since he got there, but has he been handcuffed by pressure to win now? What if the Dolphins were never that close to begin with, and now their actions are just catching up with them? Miami needs a change, but it doesn’t necessarily need it at the coaching position; it doesn’t need to hit a hard reset. There’s talent on that roster; it just needs to be filled out. If the Dolphins ever want to compete again, get guys in the door that can fill a 53-man roster to compete.