By: Rick O’Donnell
Well, it’s official. We’ve reached that point in the season where every time rumors of a team taking phone calls on players to see what the market is, they’re “actively shopping” said player. The latest out of the rumor mill is the Miami Dolphins are trying to trade Jonnu Smith as Smith tries to secure a new deal in Miami. How likely is it? There could be some traction, but it would present a problem for the Dolphins in a “more harm than good” kind of way.
Unless the Miami Dolphins are actively admitting they’re in a rebuilding phase (again), then there’s no logical reason to try and trade Jonnu Smith. First and foremost, they have zero proven TEs on the roster if they shed their lead TE. His backups are now Julian Hill, Pharaoh Brown, and Tanner Conner. While each of those names might show up on a stat sheet in the preseason, none of them have the in-game experience to step into the much-needed tight-end role for the Dolphins.
It would be a blatant misstep by Miami. The arrogance alone is almost laughable. It’s as if the Dolphins assume because they have two of the more talented WRs, Hill and Waddle, that the duo will be enough to carry that offense to victory. Both rarely have big games against division rivals and the Dolphins offense can’t seem to consistently have both receivers succeed in the same game. It does happen, but never enough when it matters. A tight end such as Smith forces teams to rethink their coverages and his backups so far haven’t proven they deserve the attention.
Then, of course, what would they get in return? Is a late-round pick enough to say “We got the best deal we could” or “We got more than we lost”? I get that money is tight, but a team that hasn’t won a playoff game in 25 years can’t go around trading one of their top receivers last year for a sixth or seventh-rounder. You can say that Smith has only had one good year, and I’ll concede, but that doesn’t mean it is a Mike McDaniel offense he wouldn’t continue to progress. Firing on all cylinders, the Miami Dolphins offense is primed for a receiver such as Jonnu Smith to succeed.
At the end of the day, Jonnnu Smith at least earned his spot with the Miami Dolphins. You can’t punish the player for the mess the GM, Chris Grier, got himself into. Your whole job is to move the money around to keep the players who perform for you happy, and Grier so far hasn’t been able to do so. The paydays are there, but their ability to keep productive players, who are good leaders, and aren’t a distraction is at an all-time low. Miami needs to find a way to make a deal with Jonnu Smith long-term without breaking the bank.