By: Rick O’Donnell
Despite the Miami Dolphins gaining chatter online as a team that can turn it around in 2025, they’ve got some way to go to be considered contenders. No matter how Mike McDaniel finishes the season, the Dolphins are more than likely to miss the playoffs this season. After back-to-back seasons without a playoff appearance, the team seems to have lost its way. So how does this team start turning things around to get back in the hunt and maybe finally win a playoff game?
When it comes to Miami, every position could use an upgrade. Either at a position or at the quality of play. So what do the Dolphins need to do? Starting with the quarterback position, where does Miami need to focus its strengths?
It all starts with Tua Tagovailoa. Not only does he need to be better. Everyone beyond him needs to be better as well. No disrespect to Zach Wilson and Quinn Ewers, but the drop-off between Tua and his backups is too great.
So let’s start with Tua. His play has been great at times, but also as ugly as it gets. That’s been his problem his whole career. He’s struggling with consistency. How does Miami fix this? First and foremost, Tua struggles under pressure, both from defenders and in big game situations. To fix this, Miami needs to, yet again, focus on the offensive line in the offseason. They’re still not where they need to be in terms of availability, but also depth. Miami’s offensive line can’t seem to stay healthy, and the guys who come in are struggling to keep the quarterback clean. When Tagovailoa has time, he’s a top QB.
So, how does Miami fix its shrinking in big games? You don’t. Unfortunately, we know exactly who Tua Tagovailoa is. There’s no fixing him in big moments as he continues to play recklessly. To counter that, the Dolphins need to bolster their defense. Balance out Tua’s mistakes with a defense that can tighten the clamps on high-powered offense. The battle for field position needs to be won by the defense and not rely on which Tua they get.
From there, the Dolphins need a true challenger for Tua’s spot at QB1. With people talking about QB controversies in San Francisco this year between Brock Purdy and Mac Jones, it highlights a need for a good backup, especially with Tagovailoa’s injury history. Backups are backups for a season. However, the Dolphins have yet to find a guy who can come in and keep the offense moving without a hiccup. Injuries happen every year, and the fall off between QB1 and his backup is too great, and the offense stops moving.
The Miami Dolphins might be better than their record shows, but they can’t rely on potential alone. This team needs some real tooling, and the focus on upgrading every position needs to be a priority for the next GM. Depth is the number one thing killing this team, and it’s time they dive in headfirst.