By: Rick O’Donnell
The Miami Dolphins haven’t performed as expected. At best, most preseason analysts had the Dolphins at 8 wins. The lower guesses were around 5. Neither looks like they’re within reach for Miami, and they look as if they’re just behind their bi-annual reset. The average coach in Miami has lasted 2.5 years post-Shula era, and HC Mike McDaniel has so far avoided the axe. So, at around the halfway point of this season, just how bad has it been?
Offense: D
The Dolphins have had their share of struggles on offense. While they’ve had bright spots from players such as Jaylen Waddle and De’Von Achane, the rest of the unit has struggled. QB Tua Tagovailoa, who is known for his accuracy, continues to struggle with turning the ball over. Star WR, Tyreek Hill, went down with an injury and was lost for the season. If not for the explosive plays to their younger stars, Miami would be pushing the boundaries of its worst offense in team history.
Defense: F
If “defense wins championships”, it perfectly explains why the Dolphins are struggling. Other than their game against the Atlanta Falcons, the Dolphins haven’t been able to stop the run. While their younger draft picks are making a difference, they have a long way to go. With that being said, playmakers such as Bradley Chubb, Jaelen Phillips, and Chop Robinson so far haven’t lived up to expectations. With injuries piling up in the secondary, the Dolphins can’t seem to stop teams from having their way.
Special Teams: C
With kickoffs playing less of a role in the game, the majority of the special teams plays come from punt coverage. While Miami isn’t terrible here, they’re also not doing anything out of the ordinary. Field goals and extra points are middle of the road, punting is ok (ish), and tackling on returns could be better. This unit wreaks of average.
Coaching: C+
Mike McDaniel’s fingerprints are all over the offense. There have been games where he has frustrated opposing head coaches. Unfortunately, clock management and challenges aren’t his strong suit. Not to mention, he’s not the only coach on the team. The offense is struggling, and the defense is growing, but the team can’t seem to stay consistent at all. There’s absolutely no sense of urgency, and penalties continue to hold the Dolphins back. A good strategy is negated by poor discipline, which falls on the staff to correct.
The Miami Dolphins showed promise at the start of the Mike McDaniel era. Now you can see the difference in press conferences, just how much the team needs a change. They want to go from fun and energetic to no one seeming like they want to be there. This team has lost its way, and that’s why we’re giving the Miami Dolphins an overall grade of a D for the midway point of the season.