By: Rick O’Donnell
John Madden and Pat Summerall set the tone in the broadcasting booth for the NFL for years. Many have considered them to be the best duo ever to call the game. Now they’re story has been given new life in the book Madden & Summerall: How They Revolutionized NFL Broadcasting by Rich Podolsky.
About The Author (from Google Books)
Rich Podolsky has been an established writer and reporter since the 1970s, covering the Miami Dolphins and writing for The NFL Today. He has been a staff writer for CBS Sports, and has written for The Philadelphia Daily News, The Palm Beach Post, The Wilmington News-Journal, TV Guide and ESPN. He is also the recipient of the prestigious Keystone Press Award for writing excellence from the Pennsylvania Publishers Association. He has written about the business of sports on television many times and is a columnist for David Halberstam’s Sports Broadcast Journal. His passion for music of the ’60s and ’70s fueled his desire to write about it. In Don Kirshner: The Man with the Golden Ear (foreword by Tony Orlando), and Neil Sedaka, Rock ‘n’ Roll Survivor (foreword by Elton John), he tells the inside story of their success.
What Works
The storytelling is key in this book. It feels authentic and comes across naturally. More often than not, when you’re reading a book about others, be it autobiographical or not, it will come off as bloated. You get the sense that whoever is writing it is trying to punch up the story a bit and add a little extra flair. Not in Madden & Summerall, though. From the forwards by Joe Buck and Troy Aikman to the journeys of Madden and Summerall to the broadcast booth, there’s no point where you feel it didn’t happen as described. You get a real sense of these two men and how they became stars.
But they didn’t start out that way, and it plays out in almost a relatable way. All those years ago, the book goes into how John Madden struggled to go from the football field to the broadcast booth. The story goes into depth about the early career of Madden, and it feels all too familiar to another football legend in Tom Brady. In his first year in the booth, critics were a bit tough on Brady this past season. If anyone needs to be handed this book, maybe those stories could be passed along to him. Surely one of the greatest to play the game would appreciate the stories in the book about loosening up and the importance of authenticity.
That’s the largest takeaway from Madden & Summerall: How They Revolutionized Broadcasting. When it came to the best team in the business, this is a story on how to be yourself and how having the right person at your side can take you to a point where you’re creating something that will last a lifetime.
What Doesn’t
It’s hard for something to be classified as not working in a book like this. For all intents and purposes, it’s a straightforward book. But in fairness, it has to be the style of book for you. What I mean is it would be great for history buffs.
Personal preference, when it comes to these types of books, is a first-person driven narrative for me. Those books are out there and at times are referenced in the book. Credit to Rich Podolsky, though, the stories he’s telling don’t linger too long, and at times, made me want to pick up those books as well.
So to call it bad wouldn’t be a fair assessment of the author. However, it is important as a reader to know what you’re holding in your hand before you decide to read it. It’s barber shop talk, which goes hand in hand with sports more often than not, so it doesn’t feel out of place. For me, it would come off better as an audiobook or a sports documentary. It’s not my personal preference on how to consume this sort of information, so it was lost on me. The book itself is great, but I really am just nitpicking here.
Madden & Summerall will be available for purchase in September of 2025 from Lyons Publishing. It will be available as a hardcover (240 pages) and eBook, and should be a great addition to the sports aficionado’s bookshelf.