By: Rick O’Donnell
The Miami Dolphins had an impressive defense in 2024, ranking in the top 10 of the league. Unfortunately, that was before they lost key pieces on the defensive side of the football. With a rebuilt defense in a new system, it might be tough to get things under control early on. There are plenty of high-skill players left, but an overhaul of the unit could be a key to their success throughout the season.
It will always hurt when you lose a staple on defense, such as Calais Campbell. The rumors of Jalen Ramsey’s departure are a tough pill to swallow. Losing players who come up in clutch positions hurts. Watching Jevon Holland sign elsewhere was painful. Yet, the show must go on, but there’s definitely a cause for concern.
The complete lack of attention to the defensive back position is a head-scratcher. Miami is gambling with the unit that someone will step up and be as good as the guy they replaced, if not better. In that mix are free agent signings Ashton Davis, Ifeatu Melifonwu, and fifth-round pick Dante Trader Jr at the safety position. Then, there are holdovers such as Storm Duck and Cam Smith who need to step into their roles a bit more.
If you’re looking at the roster and wondering which player strikes fear in opposing defenses but don’t see one, don’t worry. You’re not alone. Confidence in the unit might be at an all-time low, but it’s what Miami did about it that should be a conner. Spoiler alert, it’s nothing.
The Dolphins knew going into this season what they had, but instead focused on the front seven first. That’s great news, because they needed to. Unfortunately, here’s the problem. The focus on getting faster and more physical upfront is great. The idea that getting after the quarterback will help slow teams down is a brilliant strategy, except it’s not.
The Miami Dolphins play in the AFC. Getting fast, strong, physical players up front is what all 32 teams try to do. Having guys who disrupt a QB is a staple of throwing off timing upfront, but you still have to have above-average DB play, and we haven’t seen that out of the current group. Can they get there? Maybe, but it’s a gamble if they don’t.
The main problem is, the AFC isn’t filled with traditional pocket passers. Guys such as Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, and Lamar Jackson are making plays outside the tackles. They extend plays with their legs. Pash rushers need to be able to contain them on the outside, as well as making sure they don’t cut back and scamper over the middle. These guys are extending plays with their legs.
If they can find an extra 1-2 seconds by moving the pocket and allowing receivers to get that separation, it’s over. That’s not saying Miami hasn’t built a punishing unit upfront, but they haven’t tailor-made their attack to counter their opponents, who will surely bring that edge to a playoff position. Last year’s Super Bowl was a masterclass in how getting after the quarterback can change an offensive attack, but a good defense needs to be balanced, and I’m not sure the Miami Dolphins have that balance.